Puzzle #37 What
is wrong with this argument?
Let
A = 1.
Then
A2 = 1.
So A2 - a = 1 –
1 = 0.
But A2- A = A(A – 1).
So A(A – 1) = 0.
Now
divide both sides of this equation by A - 1 to get
A(A
– 1)/(A – 1) = 0/(A – 1),
which is the
same as A = 0, since 0 divided by any whole number is 0.
Thus
1 = 0 ?
What
is wrong with this argument?