On SUBGROUPS of the ISOMETRY GROUP of the PLANE*

James Parks

SUNY Potsdam

 

Abstract  This is a study of several subgroups of Iso, the group of all isometries of the

plane. These subgroups are generated by combinations of selected types of isometries. Almost all of the resulting subgroups so determined are semidirect products of known groups. Topological representations of these subgroups in a pair of open solid tori which represent the group Iso as an affine space are included for a more complete understanding of these subgroups and of Iso itself.

 

*See Errata to this article at http://www2.potsdam.edu/parksjm/Errata.htm

Mathematics Subject Classification 2000: 51A05, 14L17, 11E57, 54H11

Keywords and phrases: isometries, group of isometries of the plane, subgroups of isometries, semidirect products of groups, affine groups

 

1. Notation, Definitions, and Examples

This section includes a list of the four types of isometries of the plane, and several known examples of groups of isometries of the plane.  We include them here for reference and to establish notation.

            By the Classification Theorem for Isometries of the Plane: All isometries of the plane are compositions of at most three reflections in lines [3], it follows as a corollary that the four types of transformations listed below are the only isometries of the plane [3], [5].

(a) Rm denotes the reflection in line m. Reflections are opposite isometries (reverse orientations) which fix all points on line m. Reflections satisfy Rm-1 = Rm.

  (b) TAB denotes the translation by the directed line segment AB.  If A=B, then we define TAA=i, the identity function. If A /= B, then TAB = RmRn, where m//n, AB perpendicular to m, and the distance between lines m and n is |AB|/2. Translations are direct isometries (preserve orientations) and have no fixed points. Translations satisfy TAB-1= TBA.

  (c) R(P,q) denotes the rotation about the point P of angle q radians, 0 <= q < 2pi. Note that R(P,0) = i. Also, R(P,q) = RmRn, where m intersect n = {P} and the angle between m and n is q/2. Rotations are direct isometries and fix only the point P. Rotations satisfy R(P,q)-1 = R(P,2pi-q).  The rotation R(P,pi), called a half-turn (or point-reflection), is denoted by RP in these notes.

  (d) G(m,AB) denotes the glide reflection about line m in the direction of AB, for AB//m, defined by G(m,AB) = RmTAB = TABRm. Glide reflections are opposite isometries and if A/=B they have no fixed points. Glide reflections satisfy G(m,AB)-1 = G(m,BA).

 

            The following is a survey of examples of known groups of isometries of the plane.

   (A) Iso denotes the group of all isometries of the plane under function composition. The composition of isometries is clearly an isometry, and the inverse of an isometry is an isometry, by the above list of types of isometries [3].

   (B) Trans denotes the subgroup of all translations, <{TAB}, . >, where TCDTAB = TAB+CD, where the directed line segment AB+CD is taken in the usual vector sense.

     Trans is clearly abelian, and it is also a normal subgroup of Iso, Trans<Iso. For let T = Rm, m arbitrary, then TTABT-1 = TCD where CD = Rm(AB), Figure 2. All other possible conjugations of TAB will involve this product by the Classification Theorem for Isometries of the Plane given above [3].

      This same argument holds more generally for any subgroup S of Iso, S<Iso, so by the observations above we have the following lemma which we will find useful below.

 

Lemma.  A subgroup S of Iso is normal in Iso if TST-1is in S for T an arbitrary reflection about a line m, T = Rm. 

 

      In addition, Trans is isomorphic to the group <R2, + >, denoted by just R2,  Trans ~ R2, by the isomorphism h:Trans -> R2, given by h(TAB) =  (a, b), for (a, b) the translation coordinates of AB in a given coordinate system on R2.

   (C) RotP, denotes the subgroup of all rotations about the fixed point P,  <{R(P,q)}, . >, which satisfies the composition rule R(P,q) R(P,r)  = R(P,(q+r)mod2pi). This subgroup is isomorphic to the circle group S1= <{(cosq, sinq): 0 <= q < 2pi}, . >, where . is the usual multiplication on the field of complex numbers, RotP ~ S1. The isomorphism h:RotP -> S1 is given by h(R(P,q) ) = (cosq, sinq).

      RotP is clearly abelian, but it is not a normal subgroup in Iso, since we have TPQR(P,q)TQP = R(Q,q) is not in RotP, for R(P,q) in RotP and P /= Q.

   (D) Pres denotes the subgroup of orientation preserving (direct) isometries. It is a normal subgroup of Iso, Pres<Iso. For, if T in Pres, and S in Iso is orientation reversing, then S-1 is also orientation reversing, so STS-1 is orientation preserving and is thus in Pres (the case for S orientation preserving is obvious). Observe Pres is not abelian, since the half-turns satisfy RPRQ /= RQRP, for P/=Q, by the observation above on the rotation group RotP.

      Pres has index 2 in Iso, the other coset being RPres, for R any orientation reversing (opposite) transformation, since if S is also orientation reversing, then S-1R in Pres, so RPres = SPres. We will denote the coset RPres, for R orientation reversing, by Rev for orientation reversing isometries. Thus Iso = Pres U Rev.

 

2. Certain Subgroups of Iso

            Several subgroups of Iso can be determined by taking combinations of selected isometries. As we will see, many of these subgroups are isomorphic to semidirect products of well-known groups, see also [1], [2], [5]. The examples below were motivated by Example 1 that follows, see also [3] pp.19-20. A generalization of this subgroup can be found in Example 4 below.

            Example 1.  Consider the subgroup J generated by all translations TAB and all half-turns RP for points P in the plane. This collection will form a group under composition, as the composition of two half-turns is a translation. This means that J is also generated by the set of all half-turns.

Observe that J is also generated by all translations and a single half-turn RP, since any other half-turn RQ can be generated by RP by conjugation with translations TPQRPTQP = RQ.

Although the subgroup J is called the group generated by half-turns in [3], in view of the above observation on half-turns we will call J the group generated by all translations TAB and a fixed half-turn RP. The reason why we make this change will become apparent below.

J is nonabelian, since the composition of a translation and a half-turn is not commutative by the above observation on generating half-turns. J is normal in Iso, J<Iso, since RmRPRm-1 in J for arbitrary Rm by the Lemma in Section 1.  If m is not on P, then RmRPRm-1= TABRP, for A = RP(X) and B = RmRPRm-1(X), for X /= P, Figure 1. Note that R = RP in Figure 1.

            Figure 1

 

 

Trans is a normal subgroup of J, since it is a subgroup of J and Trans<Iso by the above results. By Figure 2, conjugation by half-turns RP is in fact inversion in Trans, RPTABRP-1 = RPTABRP = TAB-1 = TBA, for all TAB. Note that R = RP, and T = TAB in Figure 2.

                                                Figure 2

 

However, <{RP, i}, . >, the 2-element subgroup generated by RP, is not normal in J, since TABRPTBA /= RP, for TAB in Trans by the above observation on generating half-turns.

Also, J = HK for H = Trans and K = <{RP, i}, . >, since products of the form RPTAB equal products of the form TCDRP for CD = BA, by the above observations. All other combinations are obvious.

The subgroups H and K also satisfy H intersect K = i.

Observe Trans has index 2 in J, since if RP and RQ are any two half-turns, then RP-1RQ = RPRQ = T+-2PQ, for +-2PQ a line segment parallel to PQ but possibly of opposite direction with |+-2PQ| = 2|PQ|, so RPTrans = RQTrans.

Thus J equals the semidirect product of the subgroups Trans and <{RP, i}, . >,   J = Trans <{RP, i}, . >, and by the isomorphisms above we  have J ~ R2 Z2. This group is the generalized dihedral group of R2 and is denoted by Dih(R2) [5].

This proves the following result.

            Theorem 1.     The subgroup J, generated by all translations TAB and a fixed half-turn RP, is a normal subgroup of Iso, and is isomorphic to the generalized dihedral group of R2, J ~ Dih(R2).

 

            Example 2.  Let m be a fixed line and AB a fixed directed line segment parallel to m, AB//m. Then Hm denotes the subgroup generated by the translation TAB and the reflection Rm. This group contains the glide reflections G(m,nAB) = TnAB¡ Rm, nëZ, for nAB the directed line segment parallel to and in the direction of AB with length |nAB| = n|AB| if  n > 0, and in the opposite direction of AB with length |nAB| = -n|AB| if n < 0. It also contains the 2- element subgroup generated by Rm, <{ Rm, i}, ¡ >, and the infinite cyclic subgroup generated by powers of the translation TAB, denoted <{TnAB}Z , ¡ >, since (TAB)n = TnAB, nëZ.   Call Hm the group generated by the defining transformations TAB and Rm of a given glide reflection G(m,AB).

            Clearly Hm is abelian, thus the cyclic subgroup <{TnAB}Z , ¡ > and the 2-element subgroup <{ Rm, i}, ¡ > are normal in Hm.  Hm is not normal in Iso, since the condition of the Lemma, Section 1, Rk¡(TnAB¡Rm)¡RkëHm, is not satisfied for m not parallel to k. Also, observe that Hm = HK, for H = <{TnAB}Z , ¡ > and K = <{ Rm, i}, ¡ >, since it is abelian, and that HK = i.  Thus we have Hm equal to the direct product of subgroups <{TnAB}Z ,¡ > and <{ Rm, i}, ¡ >,  Hm = <{TnAB}Z , ¡ > « <{ Rm, i}, ¡ > È Z « Z2, [1].

            Similarly, let m be a fixed line in the plane, and let Km denote the subgroup generated by the set of all translations TAB of the plane and the reflection Rm. This group will contain all reflections Rn where m//n, since TAB¡Rm = Rn, for m//n, AB^m, and |AB| equal to twice the distance between m and n.  Call Km the group generated by all translations TAB and the fixed reflection Rm.

            If AB is not perpendicular to m, we get glide reflections in Km of the form TAB¡Rn = G(n,CD), where m//n and CD is the component of AB parallel to m. Since the product of reflections about parallel lines is a translation, Rm¡Rn = TCD, when m//n by the observation above, we have closure of the elements in Km under composition. A similar argument holds for the glide reflections in Km.  Km is not normal in Iso by an argument similar to that for Hm above.

The subgroup Km is nonabelian, since TAB¡Rm ­ Rm¡TAB, for AB not parallel to m, see Figure 3 (R = Rm, and T = TAB).  Clearly Trans is a normal subgroup of Km, Trans<Km, since Trans<Iso.

            It follows that Km = HK, where H = Trans and K = <{Rm, i}, ¡ >, since products of the form Rm¡TAB equal products of the form TCD¡Rm, for CD = Rm(AB).  Also H and K satisfy HK = i.  Thus Km equals the semidirect product of the subgroups Trans and <{Rm, i},¡ >, which is isomorphic to the generalized dihedral group of R2, Km =Trans <{Rm, i},¡> È R2 Z2 = Dih(R2).

                                                Figure 3

 

Combining these results we have the following theorem.

 

            Theorem 2.    Subgroup Hm generated by the components TAB and Rm of a given glide reflection G(m,AB) is isomorphic to the cross product of Z and Z2, Hm È Z « Z2. The subgroup Km generated by all translations TAB and the fixed reflection Rm is isomorphic to the generalized dihedral group of R2, Km È R2 Z2 = Dih(R2).

 

            Example 3.  Let P be a fixed point in the plane and consider the set of all reflections Rm where m is on P. This set generates a subgroup of Iso that we denote by GP. The subgroup contains all rotations about P, since any rotation about P  is a composition of two reflections about lines on P, R(P,q) = Rm¡ Rn, for m and n on P, properly chosen.

Recall R(P,0)  = i and note that any element of the form Rm¡R(P,q)  can be written in the form R(P,¿)¡Rm, since the equation Rm¡R(P,q) = R(P,¿)¡Rm has solution R(P,¿)  = Rm¡R(P,q)¡Rm, for ¿ = 2¹ - q.

Therefore it is possible to fix a particular reflection Rl , for line l on P, and write every reflection about lines on P in terms of this reflection and a rotation about P, since if Rm is a reflection with m on P, then the equation Rm  = R(P,¿)¡Rl  has solution R(P,¿)  = Rm¡Rl.  Thus we call GP the group generated by the set of all rotations about P, R(P,¿), and the fixed reflection Rl, line l on P.

The subgroup GP is not normal in Iso, because Rn¡R(P,q)¡Rn is not in GP when n is not on P. 

However RotP is a normal subgroup of GP, RotP<GP, since we have

T¡R(P,q)¡T -1ë RotP, for all TëGP, by the observations on RotP above.

Also, the subgroup GP is not abelian, since Rl¡R(P,q)¡Rl = R(P, 2¹-q), Figure 4. Note that R = R(P,q) in Figure 4.

Figure 4.

 Note the similarity of GP with the dihedral group Dihn of motions on a regular n-polyhedron Pn which contains the finite rotation subgroup RotP,n = <{R(P,2¹/n) , É ,

R(P,2(n-1)¹/n), i}, ¡ > as a normal subgroup.  Since RotP,n < RotP, for all n, we see that GP also contains an isomorphic copy of Dihn, for all n. As noted above RotP<GP, with conjugation by reflections equal to inversion in RotP.

In addition GP = HK, for H = RotP and K = <{Rm, i}, ¡ >, by the above observations on products in GP. Clearly RotP <{Rm, i}, ¡ > = i. Therefore GP is the semidirect product of subgroups RotP and <{Rm, i}, ¡ >, GP = RotP <{Rm, i}, ¡ >   (cf. [1] Example 1, p.178).

From the examples above we thus know that GP È S1 Z2 = Dih(S1), and we have the connection to dihedral groups alluded to above.

Thus we have proved the following result.

 

            Theorem 3.     The subgroup GP generated by the set of all rotations about P, R(P,¿), and the fixed reflection Rl, line l on P, is isomorphic to the generalized dihedral group of S1, GP È Dih(S1).

 

            Example 4.  Let P be a fixed point and n a positive integer, let LP,n denote the subgroup of Iso generated by all translations TAB and the rotation about P of order n R(P,2¹/n).

This subgroup contains all rotations of order n about any point Q in the plane, since R(Q,2k¹/n) = TPQ¡R(P,2k¹/n)¡TQP.  As a consequence LP,n is not abelian.

If n = 2 we have subgroup J in Example 1 above, LP,2 = J. LP,n clearly contains the subgroups Trans and RotP,n. The subgroup Trans is normal in LP,n, Trans<LP,n, since it is normal in Iso.  However, RotP,n is not normal in LP,n, by the above observation on rotations, thus LP,n is not normal in Iso.

We also have Trans RotP = i, and in addition LP,n = HK, for H = Trans, K = RotP,n, by the normality of Trans in LP,n. Thus we have LP,n = Trans RotP,n, and by the isomorphisms given above it follows that LP,n È R2 Zn.

Similarly, let P be a fixed point in the plane, and let LP denote the subgroup generated by all translations TAB and the rotations R(P,q) about P, 0 ² q < 2¹. As with LP,n the subgroup LP contains all rotations about any point Q in the plane, since R(Q,q) = TPQ¡R(P,q)¡TQP. Thus LP  is not abelian.

            Trans is a normal subgroup in LP, Trans<LP, since Trans<Iso. Thus we have LP = Trans RotP, for Trans RotP = i, Trans  is normal in LP, and RotP is a (non normal) subgroup of LP. Also LP = HK, for H = Trans, K = RotP, since for a given product R(P,q)¡TAB, we have R(P,q)¡TAB¡R(P,2¹-q) = TCD, where CD = R(P,q)(AB), as above in LP,n, so R(P,q)¡TAB = TCD¡R(P,q). Since Trans È R2 and RotP È S1, we then have LP È R2S1.

However, the alert reader is already aware that LP = Pres, the normal subgroup of Iso of orientation preserving isometries, so we have the known result Pres È R2S1 [5].

Thus we can also say that the group Iso is isomorphic to two copies of R2 S1, that is Iso = Pres é Rev È R2S1 é R2S1.  Since J<Iso, Example 1, we now have a pretty good idea what the quotient group Iso/J looks like. By the above results we have Iso/J = (Pres é Rev)/J È (R2S1é R2S1)/(R2 Z2) = (R2S1é R2S1)/Dih(R2).  

This means that the subgroup J is isomorphic to 2 copies of R2, Example 1, one is the normal subgroup Trans È R2 at q = 0 in S1, and the other coset RPR2 at q = ¹ in S1, all in the subgroup Pres of Iso.  So Iso/J is the set of cosets of J È R2Z2 of the form T¡(R2Z2), where T is one of the isometries R(P,q) or Rm (note TAB(R2Z2) = R2Z2).

For example, if T = R(P,q), then R(P,q)(R2 Z2) is a pair of diametrically opposite copies of R2 in the subgroup Pres at q in S1, and if T = Rm, then Rm(R2 Z2) is a pair of diametrically opposite copies of R2 in the coset Rev. More on this in Section 3 below.

Notice that the copies R(P,q)(R2 Z2) in Pres only use the range 0 ² q < ¹, since the copies of R2 in J are diametrically opposite, so they will repeat when ¹ ² q < 2¹.

Also the the slope of the line m for Rm can be identified with the copies of R2 in J by the position of J in Rev with respect to S1, that is if m has slope q, then Rm(R2Z2) is in subgroup Rev at position q in S1, 0 ² q < ¹. That the range of q is bounded by ¹ follows from the observation that slopes q and q+¹ determine the same line m, and since the copies of R2 in J are diametrically opposite, they will begin to repeat after they go through this range of q (see the topological representations below).

Combining these results we have the following theorem.

 

            Theorem 4. The subgroup LP,n, generated by all translations TAB and the rotation about P of order n, R(P,2¹/n), is isomorphic to the semidirect product of Trans and the finite rotation subgroup RotP,n, LP,n È R2 Zn.  The subgroup LP, generated by all translations TAB and all rotations about P, R(P,q), for 0 ² q < 2¹, is isomorphic to R2S1, LP È R2S1È Pres. Hence we know that Iso is isomorphic to two copies of R2 S1, Iso = Pres é Rev È R2S1é R2S1. Also, since J<Iso, it follows that Iso/J È (R2S1é R2S1)/(R2 Z2) = (R2S1 é R2S1) / Dih(R2).

 

            Example 5.  By combining the subgroups J of Example 1 and Km of Example 2 in a certain way we get a new subgroup, which we denote by Jm. This group is generated by three types of isometries: all translations of the plane TAB, all half-turns RP, and a reflection Rm about a fixed line m in the plane.

From the observations in Examples 1 and 2, the group Jm is also generated by all half-turns RP and the single reflection Rm.  As with the subgroup Km the subgroup Jm contains all reflections Rn, for n//m, and all glide-reflections G(n,AB), for n//m. Recall that the composition of any two half-turns RP is a translation, and similarly, the composition of any two reflections Rn, n//m, is a translation.

            We call Jm the subgroup generated by all half-turns RP , for all P, and the reflection Rm, for m a fixed line. Compositions of reflections Rn, n//m, and half-turns RP gives reflections Rl or products TAB¡Rl, where l^n, depending on where P is located.

Figure 5, Left shows the case for P on n, where R = RP, and Figure 5, Right shows the case for P not on n. In the case of P not on n, Figure 5-Right, note that RPRn(DABC), is a translate of DRl(A)Rl(B)Rl(C), the reflection of DABC about line l, by directed line segment Rl(A)RPRn(A).

Thus Jm also contains all reflections and glide-reflections about lines n, n^m. Since J is a nonabelian subgroup of Jm, from above, Jm is also nonabelian.

 

                                                Figure 5

 

Observe J< Jm, since Rm-1¡RnëTrans, for all n//m, so RmJ = RnJ, and J has index 2 in Jm.  Also Trans< Jm, since Trans is normal in Iso. Thus Km< Jm, since if RPë Jm, and Rnë Km, then RP¡Rn¡RP = R, for n//nÕ and nÕ = RP(n), Figure 6 (where R = RP).

However, Jm, is not normal in Iso, since Rn¡Rm¡Rn-1 ­ Rl, for l//m.  Thus Jm = (NK)H, for N = Trans, K = <{RP, i}, ¡>, and H =  <{Rm, i}, ¡ >. But H =  <{Rm, i}, ¡ > is not normal in Jm, by the observations above, so Jm is isomorphic to the semidirect product of J and Z2, Jm È J Z2 È Dih(R2) Z2.

           

                                                Figure 6

 

Combining these results we have the following theorem.

 

            Theorem 5.     The subgroup Jm generated by all half-turns RP, all points P, and the reflection Rm, m a fixed line, is isomorphic to the semidirect product of J and Z2, Jm È J Z2 È Dih(R2) Z2.

 

3. Topological Representations in Open Tori

            It is instructive to compare the results in the examples above with topological results from affine geometry theory [4], [5].

By Example 4, we know that Pres È R2 S1 and Iso is algebraically equivalent to two copies of R2 S1. This is consistent with known results in affine space theory, where it is shown that Iso is topologically equivalent to the space R2« O(2), O(2) the classical orthogonal group of degree 2.  Also, since O(2) is the union of two copies of SO(2), the special orthogonal subgroup of degree 2, and SO(2) is in turn topologically equivalent to the circle S1, we have O(2) topologically equivalent to 2 copies of S1 [4], p.12.

Thus Iso is topologically equivalent to R2« S1é R2« S1, which is in turn topologically equivalent to the interior of two disjoint solid tori, intD2« S1é intD2« S1, since intD2, the interior of the unit disc D2, is topologically equivalent to R2.

In this model one open solid torus represents the subgroup Pres, and the other torus represents the coset Rev,  Figure 7, [4] pp. 19-21.

              

                               Pres                                                                Rev

                                                            Figure 7

 

            The vertical open disc at x = +1 in the cut-away view of the Pres torus, Figure 8, represents the subgroup Trans. ItÕs complement in the torus Pres is the set of rotations. The open Mobius band intM inside the cut-away view of the coset torus Rev represents the set of all reflections, and itÕs complement in the torus Rev represents the set of all glide reflections, and is topologically another open solid torus, ibid.

                               Pres                                                                Rev                                                                                               Figure 8

            The subgroup J È R2 Z2 in Example 1 is represented in this model by two vertical open circular discs (cross sections) on diametrically opposite sides of the open torus Pres. One disc at x = +1, for q = 0 in S1 (to the right) represents the subgroup Trans È R2, and the other disc at x = -1, for q = ¹ in S1 (to the left) represents the coset RPTrans È RPR2.  Figure 9 shows the cut-away view of subgroup J. 

     

                                                              Pres

                                                            Figure 9

 

            It follows that the quotient group Iso/J looks like copies of J indexed by q as above in both subgroups Pres and Rev over the range 0 ² q < ¹, as previously described in Example 4 above.

The subgroup K­­m È R2 Z2 in Example 2 is represented by two open discs. One at x = +1 in torus Pres, which represents the normal subgroup Trans È R2, and the other coset in the torus Rev, a disc and a line, shown in a cut-away view on the right in Figure 10.  The line in the torus Rev represents the reflections Rn, for n//m, and the complement of the line in this disc represents the glide reflections G(n,AB), for n//m. The line in torus Rev is a cross-section of the open Mobius band intM determined by m, Figure 8.

                              Pres                                                                Rev

                                                            Figure 10

 

The subgroup GP È S1 Z2 of Example 3 corresponds to a pair of (horizontal) circles that are copies of S1, one in each torus. The circle in torus Pres represents the rotation group RotP. The circle in torus Rev is in the Mobius band intM and represents the coset RmRotP, see the cut away views in Figure 11.

                               Pres                                                                Rev

                                                            Figure 11

 

The subgroup Jm È (R2 Z2) Z2 = Dih(R2) Z2 È J Z2, Example 5, corresponds to a copy of J in the torus Pres, Figure 9, and a coset of J in the torus Rev, Figure 12. The line on the right side of the torus Rev represents the reflections Rn, for n//m. It is contained in the disc that contains the representative for line m. The line opposite to the left in torus Rev represents the reflections Rl, for l^m. The complement of these 2 lines in the discs shown in the torus Rev represent the glide reflections G(n,AB), n//m, and G(l,AB), l^m, respectively. These lines are cross-sections of the open Mobius band intM, Figure 8.

 

                                Pres                                                                Rev

                                                            Figure 12

 

References

[1] D. Dummit & R. Foote, Abstract Algebra, 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, 2003.

[2] S. MacLane & G. Birkhoff, Algebra, 4th printing, MacMillan Co., 1970.

[3] G. Martin, Transformation Geometry, 4th printing, S-V, 1982.

[4] E. Rees, Notes on Geometry, 2nd printing, S-V, 1988.

[5] MathWorld:  http://mathworld.wolfram.com